icepixie | Music question

Music theorists, I have a question for you. I recently heard Dar Williams's "And a God Descended" for the first time, and I found that there was something really, really musically satisfying about the first line of the chorus, or rather the first two lines, since the melody and arrangement repeats itself. (Here's a clip of the relevant part, with a bit of the preceding verse for context.) It's not necessarily that I think it's pretty, though I do, but rather that it feels very, very right that these notes/chords follow each other in this order. Is there some objective reason why I find it so satisfying, such a particularly strong resolution of the chords involved, or something like that? Or is it pure idiosyncrasy?

Also, in case anyone missed it, the Small Fandoms/Rarepairs/Rarely-written Characters Promote-a-Thon and Request Line is still going on! Come share your rare fanworks and see if other people have written things you never knew you needed!

Current Mood: curious
Crossposts: http://icepixie.livejournal.com/743496.html

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

From:

asinpterodactyl.livejournal.com

My music theory textbook had a fantastic chart inside the front cover which showed how each of the different chords likes to progress. I just attempted to reproduce the chart from memory, and while I'm sure I got a few lines wrong, the general form is accurate.

The arrows show which chords you can go to. So, for example, if you're currently on ii, you can go to V, or vii, but you can't go to iii, or straight to I, because it wouldn't sound good.

The general form that most music follows is something like this:
1. Start at I (the tonic)
2. Jump to any other chord
3. Now try to work your way back to I by following the arrows.

From:

icepixie

Interesting! That is very cool. Thanks.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

Profile

icepixie

My AO3 Page

March 2023

S	M	T	W	T	F	S
			1	2	3	4
5	6	7	8	9	10	11
12	13	14	15	16	17	18
19	20	21	22	23	24	25
26	27	28	29	30	31

Tags

adventures in cookery [16]
amusements on the intertubes [158]
ankylosing spondylitis [12]
apartment [1]
art [2]
article [1]
austen h8 [10]
ballet [3]
ballroom dancing [39]
birds [10]
birthday [7]
books [157]
- harry potter [8]
- lotr [10]
- vorkosigans [10]
buying a house [1]
choir [16]
college [74]
comps [22]
contra dance [1]
crack [7]
crazy fic ideas [22]
dead of cute [3]
dear yuletide writer [5]
dog [14]
doooooooom [4]
ehlers-danlos [2]
england [3]
england is strange [26]
exeter [38]
fail [2]
fake tv show [2]
fandom [47]
fandom addiction fairy [4]
fanvids that live in my head [3]
fic [120]
fic series
- closet idealism au (b5) [12]
fic
- snippets [4]
figure skating [207]
- spectating [33]
gardening [2]
geekery [9]
glee [23]
gonna need an ark [12]
grad school [177]
graduation [2]
grammar goddess [1]
gre [4]
grrr argh [61]
gynecological adventures [32]
health [39]
heh [43]
history [2]
holiday cards [3]
housekeeping [7]
humane society [2]
i am english major hear me analyze [26]
i have awesome friends [4]
i wonder [1]
ibook saga [7]
icons [13]
job search [5]
kenyon [93]
klutz [14]
knoxville [4]
laura roslin is my role model [1]
lazy academic [1]
library [2]
life [307]
little post of horrors [4]
media
- thrilling adventure hour [3]
- welcome to night vale [1]
meme [94]
mock mock mock [2]
mood themes [2]
movies [73]
- fred and ginger [31]
- sky captain [4]
- the cutting edge [7]
- the thin man [6]
museum [2]
music [141]
musicals [5]
my illustrious publishing career [4]
nashville [55]
octorhymo [1]
pealers [2]
photography [7]
photos [133]
picspam [1]
poetry [12]
- mine [3]
pollage [15]
puns [15]
recs [40]
scapercon
- vsc [1]
scary [15]
science fiction [6]
senior week [5]
shiny [16]
skating [1]
skiffy [2]
tea [5]
teaching [46]
thesis [58]
tooth saga [5]
trains [4]
travel [64]
- bath [4]
- bristol [1]
- california [1]
- chicago [5]
- cornwall [4]
- dartmoor [5]
- dawlish [3]
- denver [2]
- dover [2]
- edinburgh [3]
- exmouth [1]
- glastonbury [2]
- ireland [6]
- kent [2]
- london [12]
- lucerne [3]
- new york city [2]
- northumbria [1]
- oxford [1]
- paris [2]
- salisbury [1]
- salzburg [2]
- scotland [3]
- seattle [2]
- st. andrews [2]
- stourhead [1]
- stratford [1]
- topsham [1]
- totnes [2]
- washington dc [2]
tv
- agent carter [15]
- alias [5]
- atlantis [26]
  - sheppard/weir [6]
- babylon 5 [149]
  - ivanova/delenn [2]
  - ivanova/garibaldi [25]
  - ivanova/marcus [3]
  - ivanova/talia [1]
- ballykissangel [10]
- bbc [8]
- body of proof [44]
- bones [44]
- brisco county [1]
- bsg [93]
  - adama/roslin [3]
- bunheads [3]
- burn notice [26]
- caprica [1]
- carnivale [6]
- caroline in the city [6]
- castle [80]
- chilling adventures of sabrina [1]
- china beach [29]
- corner gas [21]
  - karen/davis [1]
- crusade [6]
- cupid [30]
- doctor who [86]
  - charley pollard [3]
  - doctor/rose [1]
  - eight [17]
  - eight/charley [10]
  - five [5]
  - five/tegan [6]
  - four [10]
  - four/romana [2]
  - four/sarah jane [2]
  - nine [9]
  - sarah jane smith [1]
  - six [1]
  - ten [32]
- due south [72]
  - fraser/thatcher [30]
  - yukon fic [7]
- earth 2 [1]
- farscape [25]
- firefly [4]
- firely [1]
- forever knight [3]
- fringe [96]
- futurama [2]
- ghosts [1]
- horrible histories [1]
- lois and clark [2]
- mad men [7]
- middleman [1]
- misc [36]
- miss fisher's murder mysteries [3]
- moonlighting [4]
- nashville [5]
- nikki & nora [2]
- northern exposure [56]
- orphan black [2]
- pushing daisies [33]
- rizzoli & isles [10]
- robson arms [3]
- sajv [7]
  - jules/rebecca [1]
- sg-1 [35]
  - daniel/janet [1]
  - sam/jack [12]
- sleepy hollow [3]
- slings and arrows [17]
- spaced [4]
- star trek [4]
  - discovery [2]
  - ds9 [7]
  - enterprise [1]
  - voyager [11]
- stranger things [4]
- supernatural [2]
- the americans [5]
- the crown [1]
- the invisible man [1]
- the librarians [2]
- torchwood [1]
- wandavision [1]
- warehouse 13 [24]
- wings [1]
- wonderfalls [14]
- x-files [24]
- xena [4]
useful things [4]
victorian [17]
vidding [26]
vids [30]
weird [3]
when i am old i shall wear purple [2]
work [22]
writing [133]
wrong [2]
wtf [15]
year in review [3]

Page Summary

asinpterodactyl.livejournal.com - (no subject)

Style Credit

Style: Philosopher for Dusty Foot by timeasmymeasure

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

Page generated Jan. 15th, 2026 08:32 pm

To travel hopefully is a better thing than to arrive

Music question