icepixie | The shadows were not actually the most disturbing part

Just watched "Silence in the Library"/"Forest of the Dead." Uh...did The Moff mean for the ending to be as creepy and disturbing as it was, or was he just blind to the variety of implications it has?

Current Mood: disturbed

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

From:

chickwithmonkey.livejournal.com

...no? I thought it was sweet. What's creepy about it?

From:

icepixie

River--a very active, adventuring, Indiana Jones figure--sacrifices her life to save all the people and the Doctor, and then she...ends up stuck for eternity in a database with some coworkers, taking care of three semi-real children. "Everybody lives." This is living? It's not quite as bad as Ursula-the-paving-stone, but it's not what I'd call a happy ending.

I could write it off as a character flaw of the Doctor's--that he can't leave anyone, and particularly females, their agency and allow them to die completely, but rather likes to save them at the last second, often into some kind of half-life--and be totally cool with it, except that I don't think the creators see it as a flaw.

(Also, the whole "I became ugly, but now I'm intelligent as a consolation prize!" thing made me headdesk a bit.)

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

Profile

icepixie

My AO3 Page

March 2023

S	M	T	W	T	F	S
			1	2	3	4
5	6	7	8	9	10	11
12	13	14	15	16	17	18
19	20	21	22	23	24	25
26	27	28	29	30	31

Tags

adventures in cookery [16]
amusements on the intertubes [158]
ankylosing spondylitis [12]
apartment [1]
art [2]
article [1]
austen h8 [10]
ballet [3]
ballroom dancing [39]
birds [10]
birthday [7]
books [157]
- harry potter [8]
- lotr [10]
- vorkosigans [10]
buying a house [1]
choir [16]
college [74]
comps [22]
contra dance [1]
crack [7]
crazy fic ideas [22]
dead of cute [3]
dear yuletide writer [5]
dog [14]
doooooooom [4]
ehlers-danlos [2]
england [3]
england is strange [26]
exeter [38]
fail [2]
fake tv show [2]
fandom [47]
fandom addiction fairy [4]
fanvids that live in my head [3]
fic [120]
fic series
- closet idealism au (b5) [12]
fic
- snippets [4]
figure skating [207]
- spectating [33]
gardening [2]
geekery [9]
glee [23]
gonna need an ark [12]
grad school [177]
graduation [2]
grammar goddess [1]
gre [4]
grrr argh [61]
gynecological adventures [32]
health [39]
heh [43]
history [2]
holiday cards [3]
housekeeping [7]
humane society [2]
i am english major hear me analyze [26]
i have awesome friends [4]
i wonder [1]
ibook saga [7]
icons [13]
job search [5]
kenyon [93]
klutz [14]
knoxville [4]
laura roslin is my role model [1]
lazy academic [1]
library [2]
life [307]
little post of horrors [4]
media
- thrilling adventure hour [3]
- welcome to night vale [1]
meme [94]
mock mock mock [2]
mood themes [2]
movies [73]
- fred and ginger [31]
- sky captain [4]
- the cutting edge [7]
- the thin man [6]
museum [2]
music [141]
musicals [5]
my illustrious publishing career [4]
nashville [55]
octorhymo [1]
pealers [2]
photography [7]
photos [133]
picspam [1]
poetry [12]
- mine [3]
pollage [15]
puns [15]
recs [40]
scapercon
- vsc [1]
scary [15]
science fiction [6]
senior week [5]
shiny [16]
skating [1]
skiffy [2]
tea [5]
teaching [46]
thesis [58]
tooth saga [5]
trains [4]
travel [64]
- bath [4]
- bristol [1]
- california [1]
- chicago [5]
- cornwall [4]
- dartmoor [5]
- dawlish [3]
- denver [2]
- dover [2]
- edinburgh [3]
- exmouth [1]
- glastonbury [2]
- ireland [6]
- kent [2]
- london [12]
- lucerne [3]
- new york city [2]
- northumbria [1]
- oxford [1]
- paris [2]
- salisbury [1]
- salzburg [2]
- scotland [3]
- seattle [2]
- st. andrews [2]
- stourhead [1]
- stratford [1]
- topsham [1]
- totnes [2]
- washington dc [2]
tv
- agent carter [15]
- alias [5]
- atlantis [26]
  - sheppard/weir [6]
- babylon 5 [149]
  - ivanova/delenn [2]
  - ivanova/garibaldi [25]
  - ivanova/marcus [3]
  - ivanova/talia [1]
- ballykissangel [10]
- bbc [8]
- body of proof [44]
- bones [44]
- brisco county [1]
- bsg [93]
  - adama/roslin [3]
- bunheads [3]
- burn notice [26]
- caprica [1]
- carnivale [6]
- caroline in the city [6]
- castle [80]
- chilling adventures of sabrina [1]
- china beach [29]
- corner gas [21]
  - karen/davis [1]
- crusade [6]
- cupid [30]
- doctor who [86]
  - charley pollard [3]
  - doctor/rose [1]
  - eight [17]
  - eight/charley [10]
  - five [5]
  - five/tegan [6]
  - four [10]
  - four/romana [2]
  - four/sarah jane [2]
  - nine [9]
  - sarah jane smith [1]
  - six [1]
  - ten [32]
- due south [72]
  - fraser/thatcher [30]
  - yukon fic [7]
- earth 2 [1]
- farscape [25]
- firefly [4]
- firely [1]
- forever knight [3]
- fringe [96]
- futurama [2]
- ghosts [1]
- horrible histories [1]
- lois and clark [2]
- mad men [7]
- middleman [1]
- misc [36]
- miss fisher's murder mysteries [3]
- moonlighting [4]
- nashville [5]
- nikki & nora [2]
- northern exposure [56]
- orphan black [2]
- pushing daisies [33]
- rizzoli & isles [10]
- robson arms [3]
- sajv [7]
  - jules/rebecca [1]
- sg-1 [35]
  - daniel/janet [1]
  - sam/jack [12]
- sleepy hollow [3]
- slings and arrows [17]
- spaced [4]
- star trek [4]
  - discovery [2]
  - ds9 [7]
  - enterprise [1]
  - voyager [11]
- stranger things [4]
- supernatural [2]
- the americans [5]
- the crown [1]
- the invisible man [1]
- the librarians [2]
- torchwood [1]
- wandavision [1]
- warehouse 13 [24]
- wings [1]
- wonderfalls [14]
- x-files [24]
- xena [4]
useful things [4]
victorian [17]
vidding [26]
vids [30]
weird [3]
when i am old i shall wear purple [2]
work [22]
writing [133]
wrong [2]
wtf [15]
year in review [3]

Page Summary

chickwithmonkey.livejournal.com - (no subject)

Style Credit

Style: Philosopher for Dusty Foot by timeasmymeasure

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

Page generated Feb. 6th, 2026 08:15 pm

To travel hopefully is a better thing than to arrive

The shadows were not actually the most disturbing part